A tricolor Australian Shepherd dog with black, brown, and white fur is lying down on a black surface.

Unveiling the Drawbacks: Exploring the Negatives of Owning a Sheltie

Last Updated on February 12, 2024 by admin

Shelties, known for their captivating presence and lively demeanor, can bring immense joy into the lives of dog owners. However, potential owners must be aware of the breed’s inherent drawbacks before making a commitment. This exploration delves into the challenges associated with Sheltie ownership, providing valuable insights to help prospective owners make informed decisions.

  • Prone to health problems: Shelties are susceptible to eye issues, skin conditions, and joint problems, leading to ongoing vet care and potential expenses.

  • High-energy demand: They require a significant amount of exercise and can become destructive or hyperactive if not met, demanding a lot of your time and lifestyle adjustments.

  • Independent and stubborn: Shelties can be independent and stubborn, making training challenging and requiring patience and consistency from the owner.

  • Frequent barkers: They are known for their piercing bark, which can be disruptive to both the owner and neighbors.

  • Grooming needs: Shelties require frequent grooming to maintain their coat, adding to the time and effort commitment of ownership.

  • Sensitive to changes: They may struggle with adjustments to new environments or changes in their routines, potentially leading to stress-related behaviors or health concerns.

Key Takeaways:

Prone to Health Issues: Shelties may face health issues like eye problems, skin conditions, and joint ailments.

High Energy Requirements: They require substantial exercise. Neglecting this can lead to destructive behaviors or hyperactivity.

Stubborn Streak: Their independent nature poses challenges during training. Patience and consistency are crucial.

Incessant Barking: Prepare for frequent and loud barking, which may cause disturbances.

Regular Grooming Needs: Shelties need frequent grooming to maintain a healthy coat, requiring dedicated time and effort.

Sensitive to Changes: Sudden changes in routine or environment can trigger anxiety or stress.

Could Be Highly Strung or Nervous.

The Sheltie, a beloved canine companion, possesses a cheerful disposition and unwavering affection. However, beneath their friendly demeanor, Shelties can exhibit certain negatives that potential owners should be aware of and prepared to address.

Foremost among these negatives is their tendency to be highly strung or nervous. These dogs may readily exhibit jumpiness, excessive barking, and apprehension in the face of novel situations or environments. This can manifest as excessive energy, compulsive behavior, and difficulty settling down. Such behavior can be challenging for owners seeking a calm and composed canine companion.

The Sheltie’s nervous disposition also makes them highly sensitive to external stimuli. They can become easily startled by sudden movements or loud noises, which can lead to yelping, barking, or even attempts to flee. This can be particularly problematic for families with young children or those living in busy environments.

Their sensitivity extends beyond noise and motion; Shelties are known to be highly attuned to their owners’ moods and emotions. This can make them overly dependent and easily stressed by any perceived change in their owners’ demeanor or routine. This sensitivity can also lead to separation anxiety when left alone for extended periods.

It is essential to note that not all Shelties are highly strung or nervous. With responsible breeding practices and proper socialization, these concerns can be minimized. However, potential owners should be aware of these potential negatives and be prepared to address them through training and management strategies.

Prone to Separation Anxiety.

Understanding What’s Not So Great About Your Sheltie

A Sheltie’s boundless joy and loyalty make it a coveted companion, but potential drawbacks warrant consideration before bringing one home. Their susceptibility to separation anxiety tops the list of concerns.

Imagine coming home to a cyclone of fur and claws, your Sheltie’s uncontainable excitement barely contained by the four walls. This exuberant greeting, though endearing, can swiftly turn unruly. Worse yet, it may hint at a darker, more disruptive truth—separation anxiety.

Prone to Separation Anxiety

Separation anxiety is a distressing disorder that plagues anxious Shelties when left alone. Left to their own devices, these furry friends may descend into a whirlwind of destruction, turning your home into a scene of utter chaos—think shredded furniture, overturned trash cans, even walls adorned with ‘artwork’ courtesy of their anxious claws.

Apart from the havoc wreaked upon your home, separation anxiety torments Shelties with emotional distress. Their incessant pacing, plaintive whining, and relentless barking echo their longing for your return. The psychological toll on these dogs is undeniable, making their separation anxiety a serious cause for concern.

Seeking Relief for Your Anxious Sheltie

Should your Sheltie fall prey to separation anxiety’s clutches, know that you’re not alone—remedies await. Behavioral modification techniques, prescribed by seasoned dog trainers or veterinary behaviorists, can help curb your dog’s anxious tendencies. Training your Sheltie to associate alone time with positive experiences through treats, toys, and interactive puzzles can ease their distress. Consult your veterinarian, who may prescribe anti-anxiety medication as an adjunct to the behavioral modification program.

Considering the Sheltie Lifestyle

Shelties were bred to be tireless herders. In their blood runs the desire—no, the need—to tirelessly run, leap, and chase. Providing abundant daily physical activity is mandatory, lest these energetic dogs grow restless and adopt destructive behaviors.

A Sheltie’s coat, a testament to its lineage, requires regular upkeep. Weekly brushing removes loose hair and prevents painful mats from forming.

These dogs are sensitive to sudden shifts in routine and unfamiliar environments. Therefore, it’s crucial to accustom them gradually to changes. Socialization is key to rearing a well-adjusted Sheltie, so expose your furry companion to both people and animals from an early age.

What Are the Cons of Shelties?

What Are the Cons of Shelties?

Shelties are widely cherished for their intelligence, loyalty, and captivating appearance. However, potential owners should also be aware of the breed’s drawbacks.

1. Elevated Healthcare Costs: Shelties are prone to various health issues, including eye disorders, von Willebrand’s Disease (vWD), thyroid problems, and hip dysplasia. These conditions can necessitate frequent veterinary care and hefty medical expenses throughout the dog’s lifetime.

2. Exercise Extremes: Shelties possess high energy levels and demand extensive exercise. Failure to meet their exercise needs can lead to destructive behaviors, incessant barking, and restless energy within the household.

3. Stubborn Streak: Shelties are known for their independence and stubbornness. Training them requires unwavering patience, consistency, and positive reinforcement techniques.

4. Grooming Essentials: Shelties’ luxurious double coats necessitate regular grooming to maintain their beauty and prevent matting. Owners must allocate time and effort for frequent brushing and occasional professional grooming appointments.

5. Sensitivity to Routine Changes: Shelties are highly sensitive to alterations in their routine or environment. Sudden changes can induce nervousness, anxiety, and, in some cases, adverse behavioral responses.

6. Separation Anxiety: Many Shelties struggle with separation anxiety. When left alone, they may engage in destructive behaviors, prolonged barking, and exhibit distress.

7. Effusive Greetings: Shelties often display effusive, almost frantic greeting behaviors when reunited with their owners. This can be overwhelming and could inadvertently teach them nuisance behaviors.

Shelties are remarkable dogs with many positive qualities. However, understanding and addressing their potential drawbacks is essential for prospective owners. Owning a Sheltie requires dedication to providing adequate exercise, healthcare, training, grooming, and an emotionally supportive environment.

May Be Reluctant to Go Outdoors in Wet or Cold Weather.

When considering a Sheltie, one must also recognize their potential drawbacks. Shelties are often reluctant to venture outdoors when confronted with inclement weather, whether it be rain or cold. Their aversion to wet or chilly conditions can present difficulties for owners who reside in regions characterized by frequent precipitation or cold temperatures. Persistent reluctance to go outdoors in such weather conditions can lead to additional challenges.

Are Shelties Aggressive?

Sure. Here’s an article about the negatives of a Sheltie:

A Sheltie’s aggression is a serious consideration for potential pet owners. Aggressive Shelties can be dangerous, and while they are generally not aggressive dogs, there are a handful of conditions. There are some negatives to owning a Sheltie that potential owners should be aware of. Shelties are prone to a few health issues, including eye problems, hip dysplasia, and von Willebrand’s disease. They also require a lot of exercise, and if they do not get enough, they can become bored and destructive. Shelties can also be very vocal, and their barking can be a nuisance. Finally, these dogs can be very stubborn, and training can be a challenge.

Personality traits of Shelties can turn negative if not addressed. While loving and gentle, Shelties are herding dogs and can become overly protective and aggressive if not appropriately trained. Even so, despite all the care and attention one may allot, genetics could drive undesirable behaviors. A Sheltie’s aggression can be a danger to people, other animals, and the dog itself. It can lead to the dog being excluded from activities or even being put to sleep.

If you are considering getting a Sheltie, it is important to weigh the pros and cons carefully. You should also ask your veterinarian about the health issues that Shelties are prone to and how to prevent them. Here are some tips for preventing aggression in Shelties:

  • Socialize your Sheltie puppy early and often. Expose them to different people, animals, and situations.

  • Train your Sheltie using positive reinforcement methods.

  • Provide your Sheltie with plenty of exercise.

  • Keep your Sheltie entertained with toys and games.

  • Do not allow your Sheltie to become bored or frustrated.

  • If you are having problems with your Sheltie’s aggression, consult with a professional trainer.

Shelties can make wonderful companions, but it is important to be aware of their potential negatives before you decide to get one. By understanding the potential negatives of Shelties, you can make an informed decision about whether or not this breed is right for you.

Do Shelties Have a Lot of Health Problems?

What Are the Negatives of a Sheltie?

Shelties, also known as Shetland Sheepdogs, are generally healthy and robust dogs, but like all breeds, they are prone to certain health issues. Some of the most common health problems seen in Shelties include:

  • Eye Issues:

  • Collie eye anomaly (CEA): This inherited condition affects the development of the eye, causing structural abnormalities that can lead to vision problems, including blindness.

  • Progressive Retinal Atrophy (PRA): PRA is an inherited disease that causes the gradual degeneration of the retina, leading to vision loss and eventual blindness.

  • Skeletal Issues:

  • Hip dysplasia: Hip dysplasia is an abnormal development of the hip joint that can cause pain, lameness, and arthritis.

  • Elbow dysplasia: Elbow dysplasia is a similar condition that affects the elbow joint, causing pain and lameness.

  • Skin Issues:

  • Dermatomyositis: Dermatomyositis is an autoimmune disorder that causes inflammation of the skin and muscles. Symptoms can include skin rashes, hair loss, and muscle weakness.

  • Von Willebrand’s disease (vWD): vWD is an inherited bleeding disorder caused by a deficiency in a blood clotting factor. Dogs with vWD may experience excessive bleeding after injuries or surgery.

  • Other Concerns:

  • Epilepsy: Epilepsy is a neurological condition that causes recurrent seizures. Seizures can vary in severity and can be life-threatening if not treated properly.

  • Thyroid problems: Thyroid problems, such as hypothyroidism and hyperthyroidism, can affect Shelties and lead to a variety of health issues, including changes in metabolism, weight, and energy levels.

  • Cancer: Some types of cancer, such as lymphoma, hemangiosarcoma, and osteosarcoma, are relatively common in Shelties. Cancer can be treated, but the prognosis depends on the type of cancer and the stage at which it is diagnosed.

It’s important to note that not all Shelties will develop these health problems. Regular veterinary care, a healthy diet, and proper exercise can help to reduce the risk of these conditions.

May Require Lots of Outdoor Exercise and Mental Stimulation to Prevent Problem Behavior.

Shelties, also known as Shetland Sheepdogs, are renowned for their intelligence, loyalty, and affectionate nature. However, it’s important to be aware of the potential negatives associated with this breed before bringing one into your home.

One significant drawback of Shelties is their proneness to health issues. They are susceptible to a variety of health conditions, including eye problems such as Collie eye anomaly (CEA) and Progressive Retinal Atrophy (PRA), hip dysplasia, skin issues like Dermatomyositis and Von Willebrand’s disease (vWD), and various types of cancer. Regular vet care, grooming, and exercise are essential for maintaining their health and well-being.

Shelties have a stubborn and independent nature, which can make training challenging. They require consistent and firm training from puppyhood to ensure good behavior. Early socialization is also crucial to prevent aggression toward other animals and people. If you’re a first-time dog owner or lack experience with independent breeds, a Sheltie may not be the right choice for you.

These dogs are highly energetic and intelligent, requiring plenty of daily exercise and mental stimulation to prevent boredom and destructive behavior. They thrive in active households where they can engage in outdoor activities and receive regular exercise. If you live in an apartment or have a small yard, providing sufficient exercise for a Sheltie may be difficult.

Shelties are known for their excessive barking, which can be a nuisance to both you and your neighbors. They also shed heavily, so be prepared for regular vacuuming and brushing to keep your home clean.

Despite these negatives, Shelties can make wonderful companions for experienced dog owners who are willing to invest the time and effort into training and exercise. With proper care and attention, they can be loving and loyal family members for many years.

Not Ideal for Homes With Small Children.

Shelties, with their charming appearance and friendly nature, may seem like ideal companions for families with young children. However, there are certain aspects of this breed that could pose challenges in such households, making them not ideal for homes with small children.

One significant concern is the Sheltie’s herding instinct. Bred to herd livestock, Shelties may instinctively try to herd children by nipping at their heels or ankles. This behavior, while playful in intent, can be unnerving and even painful for young children.

Moreover, Shelties are highly vocal dogs and may bark excessively. This can be disruptive for families with young children, especially during nap times or when trying to enjoy quiet family time.

Shelties also require a significant amount of exercise and attention. They are active dogs that need regular walks, playtime, and mental stimulation. Families with busy schedules may find it challenging to meet these needs, leading to boredom and potential behavioral problems in the dog.

Furthermore, Shelties have a thick double coat that requires regular brushing to prevent matting. This can be a time-consuming task, especially for families with busy schedules. Neglecting proper grooming can lead to skin problems and discomfort for the dog.

Lastly, Shelties can be prone to certain health problems that can be expensive to treat. These include eye problems, hip dysplasia, and thyroid disease. Families with small children may already have significant financial obligations and adding the potential costs of veterinary care for a Sheltie may not be feasible.

While Shelties can be wonderful companions for families with older children or individuals who can provide the necessary care and attention, their strong herding instinct, excessive barking, high exercise needs, grooming requirements, and potential health problems make them not ideal for homes with small children.

Can Be Prone to Excessive Barking.

What Are the Negatives of a Sheltie? The Barking Detriments

Shelties, known for their charm and herding instincts, can develop a tendency for excessive barking. This undesirable behavior can stem from various causes, including boredom, anxiety, or lack of training, leading to disruptions and disturbances in both household and neighborhood settings.

The Causes of Unwanted Barking:

  • Boredom: Shelties are intelligent dogs that crave both physical and mental stimulation. When deprived of these essential elements, they may resort to barking as a means of expressing their pent-up energy and frustration.

  • Anxiety: Shelties can experience anxiety due to various factors, such as separation, unfamiliar environments, or specific triggers (e.g., loud noises, sudden movements). This anxiety can manifest as excessive barking, as the dog attempts to alleviate its distress.

  • Lack of Training: Without proper training, Shelties may not understand when and where barking is appropriate. This can lead to them barking excessively in various situations, causing disturbances and annoyance.

Addressing the Barking Issue:

  • Addressing Boredom: Providing ample exercise and engaging mental enrichment activities can help curb boredom-induced barking. Regular playtime, walks, and interactive toys can satisfy their physical and mental needs, reducing the likelihood of excessive barking.

  • Managing Anxiety: Identifying and desensitizing the dog to triggers that cause anxiety can help reduce barking. This may involve gradually exposing the dog to the trigger in a controlled and positive manner, helping them become more comfortable and less reactive.

  • Implementing Training: Consistent and positive training can effectively discourage excessive barking. Teaching the dog a “no bark” command and rewarding them for remaining quiet can help establish desired behaviors. Patience and dedication are crucial in this process.

Additional Considerations:

  • Regular Veterinary Care: Shelties require routine checkups and preventive care to ensure their overall health and well-being. Addressing any underlying medical conditions that might contribute to barking can help mitigate the issue.

  • Consistent Grooming: Shelties have thick double coats that require regular brushing to prevent matting and maintain a healthy skin and coat. Neglecting grooming can lead to discomfort and potential health problems, which may trigger excessive barking.

  • Long-Term Commitment: Shelties are loyal and affectionate companions that require a long-term commitment from their owners. Providing them with the necessary care, attention, and training throughout their lives is essential for their happiness and well-being.

What Are the Behavior Problems With Shelties?

Shelties, renowned for their captivating appearance and friendly nature, can exhibit various behavior problems that can challenge owners and disrupt harmonious living.

One of the prominent negatives associated with Shelties is their propensity for excessive barking. Their innate alertness and protective instincts can lead to incessant barking, especially when left alone or in response to perceived threats. This behavior can become a source of annoyance for neighbors and strain relationships within the community.

Adding to the behavioral challenges, Shelties often display stubbornness and willful behavior. Their independent nature can make training a demanding task, requiring patience, consistency, and skilled guidance. Without proper training, Shelties may resist commands, exhibit disobedience, and test their boundaries, potentially leading to frustration and conflict.

Additionally, Shelties are prone to separation anxiety, which can manifest in destructive behaviors or excessive vocalization when left alone. This anxiety can stem from their strong attachment to their owners, causing distress and distress when separated. Destructive behaviors such as chewing furniture, scratching doors, or urinating inappropriately can be signs of underlying separation anxiety.

Possessiveness and resource guarding are also common behavioral issues in Shelties. They may exhibit aggressive behavior, such as growling, snapping, or biting, when their food, treats, toys, or other valuable items are perceived to be threatened. This possessive behavior can pose safety concerns and create tension within the household.

Housebreaking can also be a challenge with Shelties. They may struggle to learn and maintain proper potty habits, resulting in accidents indoors. This can be particularly frustrating for owners and can require extensive training and consistent reinforcement to achieve successful housebreaking.

Shelties often display sensitivity during grooming sessions, reacting with discomfort or negativity. Their thick double coat requires regular brushing and maintenance, but some Shelties can become anxious or resistant during the grooming process. This sensitivity can make grooming a challenging task for owners and can lead to avoidance or neglect of necessary coat care.

Jealousy and possessiveness are other potential behavioral problems in Shelties. They may exhibit negative behaviors towards other pets or people if they feel their position in the family or household is threatened. This can lead to tension, conflict, and disruption of harmonious relationships within the home.

Lastly, Shelties may exhibit snapping or nipping behaviors. While this is often a response to fear, discomfort, or perceived threats, it can become a serious behavioral problem if not addressed. Snapping or nipping can cause injury and create an unsafe environment for both the Sheltie and those interacting with them.